What is the United States’ biggest city located on an island?

Travel Destinations

By Sarah Anderson

The United States and Its Island Cities

As a country with a diverse geography, the United States is home to many cities that are located on islands. These cities offer unique experiences to tourists and residents alike, from tropical beaches to historic landmarks. However, when it comes to the title of the biggest city located on an island, there can only be one winner.

What Does "Biggest City" Mean?

Before we can determine which city is the biggest, it’s important to define what we mean by "biggest." In this case, we’re referring to the city with the highest population. While other factors such as land area and economic output could also be considered in measuring a city’s size, population is the most straightforward and objective metric.

Defining "Island"

The next question we need to answer is what exactly we mean by "island." Generally speaking, an island is a piece of land that is completely surrounded by water. However, there are some exceptions to this definition, such as man-made islands or peninsulas that are only connected to the mainland by a narrow strip of land.

The United States’ Island Cities

Now that we’ve established our criteria, let’s take a look at some of the cities in the United States that are located on islands. These cities are scattered throughout the country and offer a wide range of experiences and attractions.

The Competition: Which City is the Biggest?

With several cities vying for the title of biggest island city in the United States, the competition is fierce. Each city has its own unique history, culture, and attractions that make it a worthwhile destination in its own right.

Let’s Meet the Contenders

Here are the three cities that we’ll be comparing:

  • Honolulu, Hawaii
  • Key West, Florida
  • Manhattan, New York

City #1: Honolulu, Hawaii

Honolulu is located on the island of Oahu and is the capital and largest city of Hawaii. The city has a population of approximately 347,000 people, making it the most populous city in the state. Honolulu is known for its beautiful beaches, rich history, and diverse culture.

City #2: Key West, Florida

Key West is an island city located at the southern tip of Florida. With a population of around 25,000 people, it is the smallest of the three contenders. However, it is known for its laid-back atmosphere, historic architecture, and vibrant arts scene.

City #3: Manhattan, New York

Manhattan is one of the five boroughs of New York City and is located on Manhattan Island. With a population of over 1.6 million people, it is by far the largest of the three cities. Manhattan is known for its iconic skyline, world-class museums, and diverse neighborhoods.

And the Winner Is…

After comparing the populations of Honolulu, Key West, and Manhattan, it’s clear that the winner of the title of biggest city located on an island is Manhattan, New York. While Key West and Honolulu are certainly noteworthy destinations in their own right, Manhattan’s massive population gives it a clear edge in this competition.

Conclusion: Exploring America’s Island Cities

Whether you’re looking for a tropical getaway or a bustling metropolis, the United States has plenty of options when it comes to island cities. From Hawaii to Florida to New York, these cities offer a glimpse into the unique cultures and histories that make America such a diverse and fascinating country.

Further Reading: More on America’s Island Cities

  • "10 Best Island Cities in America" by Travel + Leisure
  • "Island Cities of America: From Key West to Honolulu" by Architecture Digest
  • "Discovering America’s Best Island Cities" by National Geographic
Photo of author

Sarah Anderson

Sarah Anderson, an Anchorage-based travel writer contributing her expertise to TravelAsker. Her in-depth knowledge of Alaska, both in her hometown and throughout the state, makes her the go-to local expert. From top-notch accommodations to delectable dining spots and thrilling activities, Sarah’s insightful recommendations ensure you’ll have a fantastic family trip in Alaska.

Leave a Comment