Which person ate the first turkey on Christmas day?

Holidays & Special Events

By Kristy Tolley

the mystery of the first Christmas turkey

One of the most popular and traditional dishes served during Christmas is turkey. It is a staple in many households, and it is hard to imagine a Christmas feast without a succulent turkey at the center of the table. But have you ever wondered who ate the first turkey on Christmas day? The origins of this dish are shrouded in mystery, and there are many tales and legends surrounding its beginnings. In this article, we will explore the history and origins of the Christmas turkey, and try to shed some light on this culinary mystery.

Turkey in ancient times: a brief history

Turkey has been a part of human diets since ancient times. The wild turkey is native to North America and was first domesticated by the indigenous people of the region around 800 BC. The Aztecs and other Mesoamerican cultures also raised turkeys for food and used their feathers for decoration. The turkey made its way to Europe in the 16th century, when Spanish explorers brought the bird back from their travels to the Americas. However, it was not until the 17th century that turkeys became popular in Europe as a food source.

Medieval feasts: did they serve turkey?

During the Middle Ages, feasts were lavish affairs that included a variety of meats, such as beef, pork, and venison. However, there is no evidence that turkeys were served during these feasts. In fact, turkey was not a common meat in Europe until the 16th century, after the bird was brought back from the Americas. It is possible that other types of poultry, such as geese or capons, were served during medieval feasts instead of turkey.

The arrival of turkeys to Europe

Turkeys were first brought to Europe by Spanish explorers in the 16th century. The birds were originally called "Indian chickens" because they were brought back from the Americas. The turkey’s popularity as a food source grew throughout Europe over the next century, and by the 17th century, it was a common meat in many European countries. The turkey was particularly popular in England, where it quickly became a staple food during the Christmas season.

The first Christmas turkey in America

While it is not clear who ate the first Christmas turkey in Europe, it is believed that the first Christmas turkey in America was eaten by the Pilgrims in 1621. The Pilgrims were a group of English settlers who celebrated the first Thanksgiving with a feast that included turkey, along with other meats and vegetables. However, it is unlikely that the Pilgrims served turkey during their Christmas celebrations, as they did not observe Christmas as a holiday.

Controversy over who ate the first turkey on Christmas

There is some controversy over who ate the first turkey on Christmas, as there are several claims to the title. Some people believe that the first Christmas turkey was served in England during the reign of King Henry VIII, while others think that it was the French who first served turkey during their Christmas celebrations. Still others claim that the Spanish were the first to serve turkey on Christmas day. However, there is no concrete evidence to support any of these claims.

One popular myth surrounding the Christmas turkey is that the Pilgrims were the first to serve it during their Christmas celebrations. However, as previously mentioned, the Pilgrims did not observe Christmas as a holiday, and it is unlikely that they served turkey during this time. Another myth is that Benjamin Franklin wanted the turkey to be the national bird of the United States instead of the bald eagle. While Franklin did admire the turkey and thought it was a noble bird, he never proposed it as a national symbol.

The royal connection: did King Henry VIII eat turkey?

One theory about the origins of the Christmas turkey is that it was first served during the reign of King Henry VIII in England. Henry VIII was known for his lavish feasts, and it is possible that turkey was one of the meats served during his Christmas celebrations. However, there is no concrete evidence to support this theory.

The influence of Charles Dickens on Christmas traditions

The Victorian era in England saw the rise of many Christmas traditions, including the Christmas tree and the Christmas card. One of the most influential figures of this era was Charles Dickens, whose novel "A Christmas Carol" helped to popularize many of the customs we associate with Christmas today. While turkey had already become a popular Christmas dish by this time, Dickens’ portrayal of the Cratchit family enjoying a Christmas turkey dinner helped to cement its place in Christmas tradition.

A global phenomenon: turkey as a Christmas dish around the world

Turkey has become a popular Christmas dish in many countries around the world, including the United States, Canada, and the United Kingdom. However, other countries have their own unique Christmas food traditions. In Italy, for example, it is traditional to serve a seafood feast on Christmas Eve, while in Japan, a Christmas cake made of sponge cake and whipped cream is a popular dessert.

Conclusion: the origins of the Christmas turkey remain a mystery

While turkey has become an integral part of Christmas celebrations around the world, the origins of this dish are still unknown. There are many theories and legends surrounding the first Christmas turkey, but there is no concrete evidence to support any of them. Regardless of its origins, turkey remains a beloved and delicious part of the Christmas feast.

Further reading: sources for more information on the topic

  • "A History of the Christmas Turkey" by Claire Suddath, Time Magazine
  • "The Surprising History of Turkey at the Center of the American Christmas Table" by Sarah Laskow, Atlas Obscura
  • "The True History of Turkey at the First Thanksgiving" by Andrew Beahrs, Smithsonian Magazine
Photo of author

Kristy Tolley

Kristy Tolley, an accomplished editor at TravelAsker, boasts a rich background in travel content creation. Before TravelAsker, she led editorial efforts at Red Ventures Puerto Rico, shaping content for Platea English. Kristy's extensive two-decade career spans writing and editing travel topics, from destinations to road trips. Her passion for travel and storytelling inspire readers to embark on their own journeys.

Leave a Comment