Would you say that New York is larger than New Jersey?

Travel Destinations

By Charlotte Williams

The Great Debate

The question of whether New York or New Jersey is larger is a hotly debated topic among residents and visitors of the Tri-State Area. While some argue that New York’s towering skyscrapers and bustling streets make it the clear winner in terms of size, others argue that New Jersey’s spacious suburbs and sprawling farmland give it the edge. To settle this debate once and for all, we must take a closer look at the facts and figures.

Defining "Larger": Area vs. Population

When we talk about the size of a state, there are two main factors to consider: land area and population. Land area refers to the total amount of physical space within a state’s borders, while population refers to the number of people who live within those borders. Both of these factors can have a significant impact on a state’s overall size and influence its economy, culture, and way of life.

New York’s Land Area: Facts and Figures

New York State covers a total land area of 54,555 square miles, making it the 27th largest state in the US. The state is primarily composed of diverse landscapes, including mountains, forests, lakes, and rivers. The largest city in the state, New York City, covers just 468.9 square miles of this area, meaning that the vast majority of the state is rural and sparsely populated.

New Jersey’s Land Area: Facts and Figures

New Jersey, on the other hand, covers a total land area of 8,722 square miles, making it the 46th largest state in the US. The state is known for its varied geography, including dense forests, rolling hills, and sandy beaches. Despite its small size, New Jersey is one of the most densely populated states in the US, with a population of over 9 million people.

Population Comparison: New York vs. New Jersey

While New York State has a larger land area, New Jersey has a much higher population density. As of 2021, New York has a total population of approximately 19.3 million people, while New Jersey has a population of approximately 9.3 million people. This means that, on average, there are more than twice as many people per square mile in New Jersey than in New York.

Density: Is Bigger Always Better?

While some may argue that the sheer size of New York makes it the larger state, others would argue that New Jersey’s high population density actually makes it more "crowded" and therefore less spacious. This is a matter of perspective, and ultimately depends on what factors we consider most important when defining a state’s size.

Urban vs. Rural: Which State is More "Spacious"?

Another factor to consider is the urban-rural divide within each state. While New York City is one of the largest and most densely populated cities in the world, the vast majority of New York State is rural and sparsely populated. In contrast, New Jersey is a much more urbanized state, with a higher percentage of its population living in cities and suburbs.

Economic Outlook: Which State is Thriving?

When it comes to economic growth and prosperity, both New York and New Jersey have their strengths and weaknesses. New York is home to some of the world’s largest and most influential businesses, including Wall Street and the fashion industry. New Jersey, on the other hand, has a thriving pharmaceutical and healthcare industry, as well as a growing tech sector.

Cultural Landscape: Iconic Cities and Attractions

New York and New Jersey are both home to a rich and diverse cultural landscape, with iconic cities and attractions that draw visitors from around the world. New York City is known for its towering skyscrapers, world-class museums, and bustling nightlife, while New Jersey is home to historic landmarks like Atlantic City and the Jersey Shore.

Transportation: Commuting in the Tri-State Area

One factor that can greatly impact a state’s size and accessibility is transportation. Both New York and New Jersey are part of the Tri-State Area, meaning that they share many of the same transportation networks, including major highways, airports, and public transit systems. However, New York City’s extensive subway system and iconic yellow taxis make it a much more accessible and navigable city than many parts of New Jersey.

Conclusion: Size is Relative

In the end, the question of whether New York or New Jersey is larger is largely a matter of perspective. Depending on what factors we prioritize – land area, population, density, urbanization, economic growth, cultural landmarks, or accessibility – we may come to different conclusions about which state is "bigger." Ultimately, both New York and New Jersey have their own unique strengths and weaknesses, and both are vital parts of the Tri-State Area’s rich and diverse cultural and economic landscape.

Further Reading: Dig Deeper into the Debate

  • "New York vs. New Jersey: Which State is Bigger?" (NY Times)
  • "Land Area and Population Density for U.S. States, 1790-2010" (US Census Bureau)
  • "The Economic Impact of New York State" (Empire State Development)
  • "New Jersey’s Best Attractions: Get to Know the Garden State" (VisitNJ.org)
  • "Transportation in New York City" (NYC.gov)
Photo of author

Charlotte Williams

Charlotte Williams, a cosmopolitan writer based in Wilmington, is the ultimate local expert for family travel at TravelAsker. Drawing on her extensive global experiences, from Paris to Bali, her articles are a treasure trove of invaluable information. With an intimate knowledge of Wilmington’s attractions, resorts, hotels, activities, and restaurants, she adds a maternal touch to her work, guiding readers towards creating cherished family memories in Delaware and beyond.

Leave a Comment